Copyright trolls are the ambulance chasers of the Internet. Their primary target is images used on websites. They purchase copyrights for generic images and then use software to crawl the web looking for websites that use the image. Then they send threatening letters demanding money. They wait for the website owner to call, then cut the demand in half, and settle. It’s a money-making bonanza for get-rich-quick companies and unscrupulous attorneys who’ve taken a break from frivolous lawsuits.
It’s fairly certain that copyright troll methods will be examined and curtailed at some point. Only recently, there was a rash of lawsuits against people who posted negative product reviews. Of course the courts stepped in and supported free speech and Internet freedom. They will surely step in and bite the heads off of the copyright trolls, possibly via a three-strikes rule, Internet search filtering changes, or meta data requirements.
Now let’s be clear, there are legit reasons for copyright owners to seek compensation for their work. Before you use a copyrighted photo, remember that a photographer took the picture to put bread on their table. If the photo is not an integral part of your article, leave it out or pay for its use.
First, what does copyright law say about fair use of a copyrighted work?
The rule is pretty clear: “The fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright.”
How do you know if it’s fair use?
Let’s break this down. The rule covers art, photographs, music, and written works. Essentially, anything that can be copyrighted.
The law provides these examples of fair use:
- News reporting
- Teaching and education
So how do we now if our use of the work falls within the scope of the examples provided in the law’s prose? “In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include—the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes.” In essence, what was the purpose of the use. For example, it could be a photo of a newsworthy event that you are reporting on – fair use. But a photo that you use in a news article just to pretty-up the post is not considered fair use.
It’s not just the purpose of the work that dictates fair use, it’s how the work was used and how that use could impact the value of the copyrighted work. “The nature of the copyrighted work; the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.” If the new work which incorporates the copyrighted image is a “transformative work” – what you created no longer resembles the original – it is likely fair use. If you used the image in a infographic or PowerPoint presentation, it’s considered fair use because you “transformed” the image into something else. If you’re doing a post about facial features and are just using a portion of the face from an image, it would be considered fair use.
Other things to consider
There are a few other things to consider. If you’re using a thumbnail and linking to the original location, there is greater likelihood of finding fair use than if you just post the original image because you’ve helped retain the value of the original image.
In short, you can shoot the middle finger at the copyright trolls if you simply ensure the copyrighted work you use is integral to your story or transformed and not just fluff to enhance the look of the post.
List of known copyright trolls
Many copyright trolls use Picsout software to crawl the web for potential copyright violations. The software is not 100% effective so each case must be manually reviewed. Here are some known copyright trolls.
Aflo – https://www.aflo.com
Alaska Stock Images – https://www.alaskastock.com
Amana Images – https://amanaimages.com
Arcaid Images – https://www.arcaid.co.uk
Arcangel – https://www.arcangel-images.com
Arcurs Productions – https://www.arcurs.com
Bios Photo – https://www.biosphoto.com
Blend Images – https://www.blendimages.com
Blickwinkel – https://www.blickwinkel.de
Bokelberg – https://www.bokelberg.com
Conceptual Pictures – https://www.conceptualpictures.com
CSA Images – https://csaimages.com
Die bildbeschaffer – https://www2.die-bildbeschaffer.de
DK Images – https://www.dkimages.com
Erikson Stock – https://www.ericksonstock.com
F1 Online – https://www.f1online.pro/en
FloraMedia – https://floramedia.com
Gallery Stock – https://gallerystock.com
Gap Photos – https://www.gapphotos.com
Garden wORLD – https://gardenworldimages.com
Glow Images – https://www.glowimages.com
GoZooma – https://www.gozooma.de
Gulf Images – https://gulfimages.com
Guliver Images – https://www.guliverimages.com
Hawaii PIctures – https://www.hawaiipictures.com
Hemis.fr – https://hemis.fr
Illuscope – Owned by Masterfile – https://www.masterfile.com
ISI Photos – https://www.isiphotos.net
Israel Images – https://israelimages.com
Laughing Stock – https://laughing-stock.com
Look – https://www.look-foto.de
Maground – https://www.maground.com
Masterfile – https://www.masterfile.com
Mauritius Images – https://www.mauritius-images.com
Mediscan – https://www.mediscan.co.uk
Michael Friedel – https://www.foto-friedel.com
Monkey Business Images – https://www.monkeybusinessimages.com
Mood Board – https://moodboard.com
Nature Picture Library – https://www.naturepl.com
Nordic Photos – https://www.nordicphotos.com
Ojo Images – https://www.ojoimages.com
Other Images – https://www.otherimages.com
Panther media – https://www.panthermedia.us
Pacific Stock – https://www.pacificstock.com
Panorama Stock – https://www.panoramastock.com
Peter Frank – https://www.peter-frank.info
Photo Alto – https://www.photoalto.com
Photo Non Stop – https://www.photononstop.com
Photo Shelter – https://www.photoshelter.com
Picture Group – https://www.picturegroup.com
Picture Press – https://www.picturepress.de
Pixmac – https://www.pixmac.com
Plain Picture – https://www.plainpicture.com
Science faction – https://www.sciencefaction.com
Seapics.com – https://seapics.com
Stock Connection – https://www.scphotos.com
Stock Food – https://usa.stockfood.com
Stock Fresh – https://stockfresh.com
Super Stock – https://www.superstock.com
Trunk Archive – https://www.trunkarchive.com
Vario Images – https://www.vario-images.com
View Pictures Limited – https://www.viewpictures.co.uk
Visual Photos – https://www.visualphotos.com
ViVo Zoom – https://www.vivozoom.com
Westend 61 – https://www.westend61.de
Wide Stock Photo – Looks to be defunct at this time.